I wish I was a better writer so I could put everything I’m feeling into lovely verses or flowing dialogue for you. I’d love to let some of this paranoia go right about now and get straight down to business but that’s never been my style. I overanalyze and torture myself with minute details that mean nothing in the end anyway. I barely sleep four hours a night and just as I’m getting to that good part of the REM cycle it’s 6am and I’m half-waking up to the morning news on whatever channel had the best late night celebrity guest from the evening before. Inevitably my dreams get intertwined with the stories on the television and before I know it I think my comforter is trying to strangle me on top of a three story Brooklyn building and my cat is a pitbull trying to bite my feet off. I can’t entirely explain my mind or why I feel like my life is best explained with a metaphor of dried up leftovers in a sticky refrigerator but I can try to explain how I know life has a little more in it than what I typically give it credit for.
I came to the realization not too long ago that we are stamped in this life by the things we love. The fingerprints of the things we love are crawling all over skin all day long whether we’re aware of it or not. When I was young I remember loving things like tv shows, shoes, comfy pillows, and new CDs. Everything I consciously remember loving was materialistic. I saw no problem in this and probably figured that everyone felt that way. As girls I knew started taking an interest in boys and gave up all that we once thought was thrilling – singing along to Broadway show songs or learning to dance like Beyonce – I was left on my own to explore my pasttimes. Sure I found a young gentleman here or there that was “cute” or “funny” but nothing clicked the way it did for my friends. Being brought up on Gene Kelly musicals and Audrey Hepburn dramas, I was doomed to believe in the most artificial romantic love there is. I believed, very strongly, that nothing could live up to my expectations in real life so why even try? Coming from a childhood that was way too realistic for my liking I immersed myself in this imaginary world where the only place I could find an honest, all encompassing love was in a video store. I was worried at a very young age that I would suffer my entire life from a strange disorder or at least be obsessive compulsive.
Then I found something more beautiful than anything I could’ve imagined. Years ago it was popular to write in an online journal and share all of your personal information with friends. Although I never understood why someone would want to do that my best friend made me one against my wishes. Instead of using it to verbally defile classmates and write poems about how much I hate my parents because they grounded me for leaving a wet towel on the bathroom floor, I used it as a movie journal. I was too embarassed to actually have anyone I knew in real life as a friend on this silly online site so I took advantage of a compatibility option the website had. Pretty much the little computer hands would take a group of interests from your profile and match you up with a list of people you would possibly have something in common with from all over the world. I had never met someone online before and always imagined it to be rather creepy but I couldn’t control myself when a person from West Virginia with 98% similarity popped up on the screen. His name was Andrew and he was perfect in my 16 year old head. Writing to express our mutual love of Marvin Gaye, Jimmy Stewart, and Curb Your Enthusiasm felt strange at first but somehow I figured he’d understand – I mean we’re 98% compatible!
And we were compatible. We started talking online for months. Both of us were extremely shy, nervous, and loved Woody Allen so we decided to meet. It never once dawned on me that meeting a man five years older than me who was traveling from five hours away to meet me in the middle of New York City would seem crazy to anyone but apparently my mother found it odd. I was 18 and legal at this point so I didn’t understand what the big deal was. Yes, there was one time we were watching some TV and saw him as a defendant on Judge Judy but that was sheer coincidence (coincidence I thought merely proved we were supposed to be together). My family seemed to believe he was a murderer or rapist. Clearly this was not the case I would insist – I’ve been talking to him online every night! I couldn’t be detered even with thoughts of a grusome death or a fifty five year old pedophile walking through the train station. I knew in my heart it would be my 23 year old soul mate.
On the day we decided to meet I stood in exasperation. I wore an Annie Hall-like ensemble in the hopes that he would get the reference and waited for Prince Charming. I remember hugging my mother that morning like it was the last time I was ever going to see her. She may have even had tears in her eyes. Finally, after what seemed like four hours of me contemplating asking a security guard to stand with me and pretend he was my father, a tall, balding, young man with bad teeth and black Johnny Cash shirt started walking towards me. This sad, confused looking person was not at all what I had expected. He looked so… Southern?
“Andrea?”
Did I fail to mention our names were similar too?
“Andrew?”
“Yes.”
Oh god. He had a slight southern drawl mixed with something I took as British. My name never sounded as good as when it came from his lips – lips that were perfection. Seeing that my first impression was of surprise and confusion I don’t know why I took to him so fast.
“I like your Annie Hall outfit there. I didn’t know who you were at first but I still felt like I wanted to talk to you.”
Maybe that’s why.
“Yeah. I love your shirt. You want to get some coffee?”
“Yeah I just need to take my suitcase over to the hotel. Want to come?”
“Yeah.”
What?! I just offered to go to some stranger’s hotel room in a big city where no one can hear me scream against my better judgement all because we like the same movies? At this point I generally decided that I was going to a mental institution when I arrived home so I should make the most out of my final days of freedom. Coming from a family that is petrified of crossing the street alone this was all new territory to me. So we got a cab and started off to the Belnord Hotel on the upper West Side.
“You here for spring, Mister?” asks the prying cab driver.
We both look at each other.
“Yes. New York is beautiful in spring.”
He sounds like a movie character. He looks like Robert Downey, Jr. When he smiles it looks like he’s missing a tooth because it’s so far back… all these thoughts began racing through my mind. I wasn’t sure if any were good or bad. I just knew I enjoyed him looking at me with his big, sad brown eyes. An image I immediately knew would be etched into my memory forever.
At the hotel I sat quietly in a chair watching him. We felt so uncomfortable speaking that all we really had was awkward eye contact and slight smirks back and forth. I watched him neatly unpack several button down shirts and a portable CD player he immediately put on the nightstand along with three CDs he patiently dusted off and placed on top of each other. I was interested in this but what caught me off guard were his hands. He had long, slender fingers with perfectly even fingertips and veins that went seemingly down the front. I know it could sound any other set of hands but I had never been so appreciative of something so small before. His quiet presence and sweet disposition gave me time and grace to think about the tiny things I never thought of on someone else. Immediately I was loving the weird things like his chin burrowing in his neck if he bent his head down into the suitcase and the self conscious way he would run his hands through his thinning hair as if he was trying to get it to be messier than it already was. He looked so tall and capable yet all I kept feeling was loneliness radiating off him. I just wanted to hold him and tell him he could stay with me forever. He worked at Dominos back in Keyser, West Virginia and for someone so deep and withdrawn I imagined it was a difficult job to bear on a daily basis. I wanted to take him away. I had just started college several months earlier but in that moment I believed there was no place on earth I was going to get as unique an education as with him.
So I skipped a few days. That’s right. I stayed in New York for a week with this person I had just met and didn’t call a living soul to tell them. I felt like I had been carried off to a mind-changing cult. Everyday with Andrew was more confusing and delicious than the one before. We would dance in the middle of the Virgin Megastore in Times Square, find books for each other at Barnes and Noble, secretly buy each other gifts from the 24 hour CVS down the street, and try to fulfill his dream of buying the perfect pair of New York shoes to bring home with him (which we eventually found at a place called “Shoe Mania”). Thinking of going home to my little suburban bedroom with Mom and Pop hundreds of miles away from this amazing human being was unbearable. Suddenly I couldn’t imagine what my days were filled with before. Late at night we would get into bed, snuggle, and watch David Letterman. Andrew was like a little boy. He was never once rude, inappropriate, or aggressive. He would put his arms around me so tight that it made me wonder what it was like for him back home. Coming from a strict Pentecostal family I doubted he got the love and attention he needed. It was just more reason for me to be devastated when the Day came.
After seven days of no interaction with either of our families and no money left, he went took the morning train back home. On the way to Penn Station there was no funny cab driver talking about spring in New York, there were no awkward glances or silly giggles, just pure heartache. I couldn’t stop staring at his knee. It was literally impossible for me to raise my head and look in his eyes – eyes that I was possibly never going to see again. Yes, West Virginia isn’t across the world but an 18 year old college student from a paranoid New Jersey family and a 23 year old pizza man with a religious Southern upbringing never did sound right together. We arrived at the train station, still not looking at one another, and I had the most powerful moment of my life:
“You want to get breakfast, Sweetie?”, he asked me in that voice.
“Mhm.”
He then proceeded to a little coffeeshop within the station, picked up a cup and made me coffee. I watched him do this the way I had watched him unpack his belongings in the motel room that first day. He did everything so carefully and this time it was for me. No one had ever made me coffee in my entire life and he never even asked how I took it – he just knew. Somehow in this gesture I realized so much I had previously been lacking. This person cared about me in a way I wasn’t even old enough to understand. My feelings of immediate attachment to him were brought on by the innate understanding that love like that only comes around once in a lifetime – pure, innocent love. Before he got on the train he kissed me for the first time in the entire week. It was so shy, sweet, and lingering. We promised to talk even more than before and find a way to be together as soon as physically possible.
“We won’t be apart ever again after that.”
I would’ve believed anything he said. I felt confident as he walked away but the second he drifted out of sight I began to cry hysterically. This is of course the time I chose to call my mother. She thought I had been murdered and I assured that if I had been murdered I wouldn’t be able to call her. I was just brokenhearted. To this day I’m still wondering if there’s a difference.